We don’t often give out 5-star ratings here at Cycling Weekly. To quote our own scale, a 5-star product must be “Superb, best in class, and we couldn’t fault it”.
Considering the numerous products we tested in 2025, with over 250 reviews available on the site, not to mention the items we’ve evaluated for our buyer’s guides and our magazine, and the items we’re testing for embargoed launches in 2026, it truly shows that giving only 24 products a 5-star rating means it must be among the very best.
2025’s 5-Star rated bikes
The Cervelo kicked off 2025 with a bang, not only being the first bike to be reviewed but also our first 5-star one. Tim said the Caledonia-5 is a bike for all occasions, a genuine joy to ride and a near-perfect do-it-all road bike.
It is rare for a team member actually to buy a bike they have reviewed. Mainly, as there is always another one to test, and rarely time to ride our own bikes. However, for the first time in his 20-plus years, CW Editor Simon Richardson bought a bike. Not a fancy high-speed, carbon road bike, as you would expect, but an electric cargo bike.
Every millimetre of the BMC is designed to increase speed and efficiency, and it makes no compromises in this pursuit. It is undoubtedly one of the most expensive bikes we tested in 2025, a year where very expensive bikes have been almost ten a penny. However, the Teammachine does not disappoint, and was one of the best road bikes of the year.
Load one more 5-star rated bike
2025’s 5-Star Shoes and Helmets
Fizik Vento Powerstrap Aeroweave
Lightweight, well-vented, stiff, comfortable and beautifully made. What more do you need from one of the best cycling shoes? Okay, they do have a quite specific use case, as they are really only designed for warm conditions. Given how many of us do our biggest rides in the summer and spend winter indoors. The Fizik has a much broader use than you would think.
Read Simon’s full Fizik Vento Powerstrap Aeroweave 5-star review
Load one more 5-star rated shoe
Shimano MW502 Winter Boots
2025’s 5-Star Rated Parts & Accessories
The Beeline Velo 2 was the only bike computer to receive five stars in 2025. It was one that Hannah revisited out of her own interest and wholeheartedly agreed with Paul’s previous review. Its simplicity is perfect for those who have a bit of a cycling tech cleanse in the New Year.
Fizik Tempo Argo R3 Les Classiques
Like the Beeline, the Fizik was the only component in 2025, other than wheels and tyres, to receive five stars. Yes, it is a saddle, which we always say is subjective; however, the Argo R3 shape appears to have broad appeal and indeed sat well with Simon.
2025’s 5-Star Rated Wheels & Tyres
Scribe Tempus Disc/100 wheels
Speaking of which, here are the other Scribe Wheels. The Scribe Tempus Disc/100 wheels were awarded five stars by Aaron, his only 5-star review for 2025. Even with less than favourable conditions, Aaron got within a couple of seconds of his 10-mile PB with the Scribes.
Load one more 5-star rated tyre
Given the trend towards ever-bigger tyres continued in 2025, it is no suprise that Schwalbe were early adopters of 50mm+ tyres, and they did a very good job of it straight out of the gate. Two Schwalbe 50mm tyres feature in our best gravel tyres guide, with the G-One RX well-suited to near-MTB terrain.
2025’s 5-Star Rated Clothing
Sportful maintains its reputation for high-performance gear at a reasonable price with the Fiandre Shift jacket. It offers excellent breathability combined with practical features and a wide temperature operating range. While not inexpensive, it provides good value considering its capabilities.
Madison Flux Short Sleeve
It’s always awesome to see something as affordable as the Madison Flux jersey getting five stars, reassuring us that cycling is still very inexpensive if you’re willing to look for it.
The only short this year that was comfortable enough to secure five stars. The Rapha Pro Team III bibs do not, by any means, come cheap; in fact, they are among the most expensive we tested this year. Dare we say they are worth it?
I think Tim reviewed nearly the entire Castelli Espresso range in 2025, and it all scored very highly, blending lightweight, high-performance, and decent value. The jersey was clearly a standout piece for Tim, who awarded it five stars.
Q36.5 Dottore Hybrid Que LS
Andy starts his review of the Q36.5 Dottore Hybrid Que LS with the question Is it a jersey or a jacket? What Q36.5 have done here, though, is make the perfect gap filler, removing the awkward middle ground between days when you just don’t know what the weather is going to do.
Castelli Aero Race 8S jersey
Andy tends to keep things pretty neutral in his reviews; however, when he really likes something, you can tell. His 5-star review of the Castelli Aero Race Jersey was one of those where he slipped into waxing lyrical, going as far as to say it is one of the best all-round aero jerseys he has used.
Gobik Absolute 7.0 Tights
Finally, our last and most recent five-star review from Tim. When Ineos announced they would be wearing Gobik, I think we all thought, who? From Tim’s review, it seems they are making some very decent kit. Maybe one to watch in 2026.
That is it! All of 2025’s five-star reviews in one place.
We start again in 2026. What will be the trend? What products will surprise us, and which will be a disappointment? Only time will tell.
What I can tell you now, though, is that to see all of the reviews the team here at Cycling Weekly publishes in 2026, make sure to first sign up for our newsletter and regularly check back to our full Cycling Weekly Reviews page.
From the whole team here at Cycling Weekly, thanks for joining us in 2025. If you made it this far, have a Happy New Year!
