Have we hit a new low with heavyweight MMA? How much time can Ilia Topuria realistically take for himself as UFC lightweight champ? And what’s the crossover potential between Zuffa Boxing and UFC fighters?
All that and more in this week’s mailbag. To ask a question of your own, hit up @BenFowlkesMMA on X or @Ben_Fowlkes on Threads.
@INCagefighting: Which era of the UFC Heavyweight Division was worse? The modern version or the Tim Sylvia dark age?
At least in the Tim Sylvia era we knew why the UFC’s heavyweight division was so disappointing. It’s because most of the good heavyweights were over in PRIDE FC. Then a few ended up in Affliction, then Strikeforce. Once those were all out of the way, the UFC had a real heavyweight class at last.
Advertisement
WBut what’s up now? I tell you, watching that fight between Tallison Teixeira and Tai Tuivasa made me angry. It was so frustrating. I was talking to the TV, saying, “What are you doing?” Then a few minutes later I’d say it again, to the other guy this time. It was like no one wanted to win that fight. It was as if they made it go the full 15 minutes just to punish us.
And you know what’s really crazy? Tuivasa lost, putting his current losing streak at six straight fights, and he’s still ranked in the top 15 (albeit at the very bottom now). That right there tells you everything you need to know about the state of the division.
@AntEvansMMA: I took a week off work during my divorce. When I went back, there was a period of weeks where, every day, at some point, I’d just not be productive for 30-45mins at a time.
But I got through it. It got easier.
Illa taking a year off work for a divorce seems, well, odd.
Hey real quick, did your job involve fighting a person who’s done nothing for the last couple months but prepare to destroy you in a cage on live TV? Or was it maybe a little more low-stakes than that?
Advertisement
If you were too distracted by your big life upheaval, what, you might forget to answer an email? You spaced on a meeting? Big deal. If Ilia Topuria goes into a fight and doesn’t have his whole act together, he loses his title and maybe goes to the hospital afterward to get his jaw wired shut or a metal plate inserted into his face.
I won’t pretend to know what’s going on in his personal life or inside his head. But if he thinks he needed the break in order to return fully focused and ready to do this, I’m inclined to believe him. Lord knows that if he’d come back unprepared and got beaten up for it, no one would want to hear his excuses then. He’s better off taking the time now to make sure he doesn’t need any.
@justlikelasagna: Holy Volkanovski! What a masterclass performance on Saturday night….Or was it Diego Lopes that decided to literally change nothing from their first fight that allowed Volk to cruise (mostly) to an easy victory?
It’s a little of both. Alexander Volkanovski is very good at fighting. In terms of fight IQ, making adjustments on the fly, reading opponents and overwhelming them with information, there’s hardly anyone who’s ever done it like him. But also? I really have no idea what Diego Lopes was telling himself in there.
Advertisement
Obviously it’s much harder to do your stuff against the champ than it is to sit here and talk about what stuff someone else should have done. One of Volkanovski’s great strengths is that he never gives you the ball and says, “OK it’s your turn on offense now.” He just takes over a fight and runs away with it.
But Lopes had to see him getting further and further ahead, right? There had to be a little voice saying, “Oh no, it’s happening again.” And instead of trying different things or taking more risks or just amping up the aggression, he did arguably less in the last couple rounds of the rematch than he did in the first fight. How did he think he was going to win that?
Again, easy for us to say how a fella should go about beating one of the greatest featherweights of all time. But once you’ve already tried and failed once, the one thing you ought to know is that more of the same ain’t going to get it done.
@shadore66: What do you say to the idea that Zuffa Boxing will fail because there is no sustained interest in boxing in the USA? I get that they have the pay all “worked out” and have a tv deal, etc. But I swear not enough people give really give a s*** about watching weekly no-names box?
Just like with Power Slap, we have to ask what Zuffa Boxing would need to do in order for the suits to consider it a success. Because it really might not take much. When you already own the arena where the fights take place, and when that arena has its own built-in production studio, with all your existing staff to work it? Yeah, that’ll keep costs low. And if you’re not gunning for the big names in boxing, fighter pay probably also stays low. So maybe this whole enterprise doesn’t need much of a return in order to make it worthwhile for the ownership crew.
Advertisement
I guess my question would be, is that really all we’re trying to do with Zuffa Boxing? Is the goal only to run a weekly fight night-style event that doesn’t cost much and produces modest returns, just for the sake of adding an extra trickle of revenue from a different combat sport? If so, fine. But that is a long, long way from taking over boxing to save it from itself or whatever.
@braiiinnnnn: early thoughts on max vs Charles?
Both of them seem like they should be on some sort of decline by now, don’t they? But they’re not. They might not be champ material any more, but they both pop back up every once in a while to remind us that they’re still better than 97% of the fighters out there. So what happens when they fight each other? Someone has to lose.
I favor Max Holloway in this fight, but not by much. Charles Oliveira has proven to be full of surprises, and when he’s on he has a bunch of different ways to beat you. But Holloway is the more consistent fighter. There just aren’t many weak spots in his game. Or, if there are, you have to be the best in the world to find them.
@RealFakeSamDunn: If there was a big ol dang ol openweight tournament a couple weekends from now and everyone on earth could enter, WHO WOULD WIN?
Everyone on earth?? In that case I assume we’re not talking about a one-night tournament. This thing sounds like it could take a while.
Advertisement
If you’d asked me a few years ago, I would have said Jon Jones. Now I’m not so sure. If the tournament were two or three years from now, I might say Gable Steveson would end up being a favorite. But if it’s happening a couple weekends from now and is open to absolutely everyone, hell, I don’t know. The winner might be playing in the Super Bowl this weekend.
@LyceumLibations: Do you think UFC stars will be able to transition back and forth to Zuffa boxing? This could be a major conflict if they’re able to make more $$$
UFC CEO Dana White has said that won’t happen, and he seems pretty adamant about it. That seems no fun to me. I’d think the benefit of owning multiple combat sports brands and having hundreds of fighters under contract would be the ability to mix and match them to create interesting, headline-grabbing fights.
But if the pay from Zuffa Boxing turns out to be so much better than pay in the UFC, you’re not going to keep it a secret just by keeping the fighters separate. Not in the year 2026. But it’s not like MMA fighters don’t already know that top boxers earn way, way more than they do. They also can’t claim ignorance on the overall revenue picture. By now, everybody knows the UFC is raking in billions every year and paying fighters less than 20% of it. That’s no secret. It’s just that fighters haven’t been able or willing to do anything to nudge up that number. I don’t see that changing just because there’s boxing in the same building now.
