The Yankees' season a year ago ended because of their poor defense and it felt familiar in 2025.
While the offensive woes are largely to blame for the Yankees' season-ending 5-2 loss to the Blue Jays in Game 4 of the ALDS, one defensive play in particular helped Toronto blow the game open.
In the sixth inning, with the Blue Jays up just 2-1, starter Cam Schlittler allowed a one-out single to Ernie Clement before getting Andres Gimenez to hit a sharp grounder to Jazz Chisholm Jr. The ball skipped up on the second baseman and went into the outfield, putting runners on the corners with one out. Manager Aaron Boone brought in Devin Williams to try and get out of the jam, but after a George Springer strikeout, Nathan Lukes singles into left-center to drive in two runs.
Even though the deficit was just three runs, with just two Yankees hits against the myriad of Blue Jays relievers up to that point, it felt like 10.
“Didn’t think it would play the way it played and just missed it," Chisholm said of the play after the game. "Been thinking about it since the play happened, still thinking about it now, can’t get it out of my head. Got to move on eventually, have three months to move on. Will probably think about this when the season starts next year."
"Just ball hit sharply, but one he's going to turn all the time," Boone said. "Just missed — it just kicked off. Sharply hit ball, but a one-hopper, one he's going to turn all the time. And it just looked like it skipped off his glove."
Although the Yankees played relatively clean baseball in the ALDS, against a team like the Blue Jays extra outs and mistakes — allowing runners to take extra bags — came back to hurt New York. When asked why the Yankees fell to Toronto, Aaron Judge pointed to those types of plays.
"It comes down to the little things. Making little plays, come up with the big hit. If you don't do that, give teams extra outs, they're going to capitalize on it." Judge said. "What a season for the Blue Jays. Doing their thing, winning the division, winning the DS. For us, we have to clean a couple of things up and come right back here."
Chisholm lauded this Yankees team as being the top in the American League, despite the ups and downs of the season. While he does still believe they were the best team, the Yankees infielder attributed their elimination to the Blue Jays outplaying them and baseball doesn't always reward the best teams.
"I wouldn’t say [we underachieved], we all thought we were the team to win the World Series, but baseball’s baseball," he said. "Baseball can take a turn in any way; baseball favors nobody. For us, we have to keep rolling with the punches."
